Students who invent math rules learn 10x deeper
Transform passive problem-solvers into active pattern creators
Hey there,
My high school math teacher used to say something that stuck with me for decades: “If you can’t explain why the formula works, you don’t really understand the math—you’re just a human calculator.”
This is a podcast overview of the entire newsletter in case that you prefer to listen to it in this format. This podcast overview was created with NotebookLM.
Back then, I didn’t fully appreciate what he meant. I could plug numbers into the quadratic formula and get the right answer. I could solve for x. I could pass the tests. But could I explain why those formulas worked? Could I create my own mathematical rules from scratch? Absolutely not. And honestly, neither could most of my classmates. We were all just following instructions, memorizing steps, hoping we’d remember them long enough for the exam.
Fast forward to my years as a computer teacher, and later as an education consultant in project-based learning and AI in education, and I finally understand what my teacher was trying to tell us. Real mathematical thinking comes from creation, discovery, and ownership. When students become the creators of mathematical rules rather than just followers of them, something magical happens. They internalize concepts in ways that no amount of worksheets ever could.
Today’s post is sponsored By: Project Pals
Spark scientific curiosity and critical thinking with our collection of forensic science project-based learning resources designed for middle and high school classrooms. Our forensic science lesson plans transform students into investigators who apply real scientific methods to solve compelling mysteries and analyze evidence. Featured projects like “How can we apply forensic science techniques to solve a mock crime scene investigation?” provide students with authentic learning experiences where they collect and analyze evidence, document findings, and draw evidence-based conclusions. This hands-on approach to forensic science education reinforces core scientific principles while developing practical skills valued in STEM fields. Each forensic science project aligns with both Common Core and NGSS standards, making implementation seamless across science curricula.
Today, I want to share something that brings this philosophy into the age of AI in a way that helps students learn deeper, not cheat faster.
What you’ll discover today
How AI can act as a Socratic guide (not a homework machine) for elementary math
Why having students create their own math puzzles builds true understanding
A ready-to-use prompt that turns students from rule-followers into rule-creators
Let’s dive in.
Resources to explore
If you want to use AI as a genuine learning tool that develops critical thinking and mathematical creativity in your students, here are some resources to explore:
Weekly resource list
The Socratic Method in Elementary Math (20 min read) — A fascinating transcript showing how pure Socratic questioning helped third-graders discover binary numbers with no direct teaching
How the Socratic Method Sharpens Critical Thinking (8 min read) — Practical guidance for middle and high school teachers on using question-driven instruction that makes students do the thinking
AI Tutoring Systems and Personalized Learning (Research paper, 25 min read) — Comprehensive review of how intelligent tutoring systems use AI to provide adaptive instruction while modeling student psychology and progress
The Future of AI in Education: U.S. Department of Education Report (Full report, 60 min read) — Essential reading on AI’s role in teaching and learning, including how to align AI models with educational visions rather than limiting learning to what AI can do
How AI Tutoring Personalizes Learning Without Replacing Teachers (7 min read) — Balanced look at AI tutoring benefits and limits, including important cautions about data privacy and algorithmic bias
Math rule creation: When AI becomes a thinking partner, not an answer machine
The wrong way vs. the right way to use AI
Here’s what most people get wrong about AI in education: they worry it’ll make students lazy, that kids will just ask ChatGPT for answers instead of doing the work themselves. And honestly? That’s a valid concern when AI is used poorly.
But what if we flipped the script entirely? What if instead of asking AI for answers, students used AI to help them create the questions?
How it works: Students as mathematical creators
That’s exactly what the Math Rule Creation prompt does. It’s an AI-powered Socratic guide designed for elementary students in grades 2-5, and it does something remarkable: it helps students design their own mathematical rule puzzles using a 5×5 matrix grid without ever telling them what to do.
Why this changes everything
Traditional math instruction often works like this: Teacher explains a rule, students practice the rule, students take a test on the rule. The student’s role is passive—absorb, repeat, regurgitate.
When students become the creators of mathematical patterns, everything changes. They have to think deeply about what makes a rule consistent, how patterns work, why certain operations produce predictable results. They’re not just following someone else’s thinking anymore. They’re doing the thinking themselves.
The Socratic questioning approach
The AI acts purely as a Socratic questioner, asking open-ended questions that guide discovery without providing specific examples, rules, or numbers. It asks things like “What operations do you feel comfortable using?” and “How will you decide what numbers to use?” and “Does your rule work consistently throughout your matrix?”
The student makes every single decision. The AI simply asks the questions that help them think through their choices.
Five ways this builds real mathematical understanding
This approach builds genuine mathematical understanding in several powerful ways:
First, it develops deep understanding of patterns and sequences. Students can’t create a consistent pattern without truly grasping how it works.
Second, it builds algebraic thinking before formal algebra by having students work with variables and relationships in a concrete, visual way.
Third, it encourages mathematical creativity and ownership. This is their puzzle, their rule, their creation.
Fourth, it strengthens logical reasoning and consistency checking as students test whether their rules actually work.
And finally, it helps students internalize mathematical operations through creation rather than memorization.
The patient guide that never gets frustrated
This AI guide provides individualized, patient one-on-one guidance to every student simultaneously. It never gets tired, frustrated, or impatient, asking the same encouraging guiding questions whether it’s the student’s first attempt or tenth revision. It adjusts questioning complexity based on each student’s grade level and mathematical comfort.
What this looks like in action
Students move from passive problem-solvers to active rule-creators, leading to better internalization of mathematical concepts through discovery rather than memorization. They’re not just plugging numbers into formulas anymore. They’re understanding why those formulas work because they’ve experienced the thinking process that creates them.
A real example: Third grade in action
When I tested this with a third-grade student, the interaction was remarkable. The AI asked the student what grade they were in, what math operations they felt comfortable with, whether they wanted their numbers to grow or shrink. Step by step, question by question, the student designed a matrix where each column followed its own rule—column one grew by ones, column two by twos, column three by threes. The student chose everything: the starting numbers, the operations, which cells to leave blank for others to solve.
At no point did the AI say “try adding 5” or “multiply by 2” or “here’s an example.” It simply asked questions that helped the student think through their own choices. When the student finished, they had created a genuine mathematical puzzle—one that required real thinking to solve, and one that they fully understood because they had built it themselves.
This is AI done right
This is AI used the right way in education. Not as a shortcut that does the thinking for students, but as a patient guide that helps students do their own thinking more effectively. Not as a replacement for teachers, but as a tool that allows teachers to give every student the kind of one-on-one Socratic guidance that would be impossible in a classroom of 25 kids.
Key takeaways
That’s it.
Here’s what you learned today:
Students develop deeper mathematical understanding when they create rules rather than just follow them
AI can serve as a Socratic guide that asks questions without providing answers, helping students discover concepts through their own thinking
The Math Rule Creation prompt turns elementary students from passive problem-solvers into active pattern-creators, building genuine mathematical reasoning
Your next step
The next time you’re tempted to dismiss AI in education as “just another way for kids to cheat,” remember this: the problem isn’t the technology, it’s how we use it. When we design AI tools that make students think harder, not less, we unlock possibilities that weren’t possible before.
Try the Math Rule Creation prompt with your students this week. Watch what happens when you give them the power to be the mathematical creators instead of just the consumers. You might be surprised at how much they understand when they’re the ones building the rules.
PS...If you’re enjoying Master AI For Teaching Success, please consider referring this edition to a friend. They’ll get access to our growing library of AI prompts and templates, plus our exclusive “Popular AI Tools Integration Guide For Teachers“ implementation guide.
Didn't expect this take. Remindes me of inventing Pilates moves.